Skip to main content

Critique Group vs. Hiring a Writing Coach: Pros & Cons

Dear Alison and friends,

I planned to talk about the Monroe County Book Expo last Saturday and all about my book display and how to setup book displays and where to buy all the swag for it, but something else came to mind, so I will write that planned post, another day... 


For this post, I wanted to talk about the Pros and Cons of Critique Groups vs. Hiring a Writing Coach.


Last night, I taught a Nuts and Bolts class for beginner writers. I love teaching beginner writers--they're so excited about their writing and getting published, but as we know, the reality after five years together is that it ain't easy. There's actually a hell of a lot more stuff about writing and the steps to publication than I ever imagined when I first started. I shared my battle scars, errr... knowledge with them, and I  thought to myself,  "Kim, you should share your insight with all your readers too."

So Writer, you’ve written a manuscript. You’ve read, revised, reread, revised, read, and revised more times than you care to remember and certainly more than you can count. What’s next???

First, mostly likely your manuscript is not ready for submission. The most common mistake writers make is submitting their manuscript before it’s ready. I am guilty of this crime.



Here’s what you do instead…

JOIN a Critique Group OR Hire a Writing Coach 

Let’s look at the pros and cons of Critique Groups and Writing Coaches.

CRITIQUE GROUPS: A group of writers who meet on a regular basis. They exchange pages ahead of time or share their work the day of the meeting. All members SHOULD provide both positive and constructive feedback on other members’ work.

What you’re writing will dictate where you should look.
            POSSIBLE STARTING POINTS…
·      SCBWI (Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators) Children’s Book (PB –YA) search your local SCBWI page for information.
·      Fantasy/Sci-Fi Organizations
·      RWA (Romance Writers Association)
·      Meetup.com (yep, I know a lot of writers who met through this site.)
·      Online Writing Groups
**ALWAYS REMEMBER BUYER BEWARE. YOU SHOULDN’T PAY FOR THIS SERVICE.

            PROS of joining a CRITIQUE GROUP:

·      EXPERIENCE: Depending on the group, you might have other writers of a more experienced writing background from you. You can pick their brains…

**BEWARE: more years writing, does not ALWAYS mean more experience or GOOD advice giver. More experienced and successful writers, don’t normally open their groups up to newcomers, so tread with caution.

·      FRIENDSHIP: New group means the other writers are probably about the same skill level as you. View it as an opportunity to develop friendships and develop your writing craft together. When the rejections come (because they will), they will be there to pat you on the shoulder and if you’re lucky, give you chocolate.

·      KEEP IT POSITIVE: Find a positive group. If you give more than you receive, you need to reevaluate if that group and the people are working for you. Remember a little sugar goes a long way.
**There are haters everywhere. If you’re not happy, change groups.

CONS:
·      Lack of experience.
·      Not doing the work. Barely commenting or offering anything useful to anybody.
·      Not putting the time in. Taking but never giving.
·      Advice overload.
·      Finding a group that you click with and fits in with your schedule.

**NOTE: I met my writing BFFs Alison and Donna from critique groups, so obviously I am a huge fan of them, but there can be disadvantages. We're not really a critique group anymore. We've evolved into trusted readers, and believe me, they are hard to come by. Honestly, at the beginning of your writing, the people you trust may not (and usually aren't) the same as a trusted reader. Consider the trusted reader when you become a more advanced writer.


OR 2ND OPTION… Hire a Writing Coach

PROs:
EXPERIENCE: Writing Coaches have been there. Done that. Extensive background with books to their credit. Spends time improving her (or his) craft. Has been through every step of the process—both good AND bad.
KNOWLEDGE:
·      Knows the category, genre, target audience.
·      Knows the market.
·      Knows agents, editors, cover designers, illustrators, and other people in the writing business.
·      Knows what social media platforms are and how to use them. **Also when to develop them.
                   SPEED:
·      Fast turn around—You don’t need to read anyone else’s work in order for them to read yours.
·      Saves you time. No extra meetings. No obligation to read other work.
·      Emails delivered to your inbox. Phone consultations scheduled at your convenience.
EXPERT ADVICE:
·      You don’t need to weed through all the advice from multiple parties and figure out what’s helpful and what isn’t.
·      Provide confirmation when you’re on the right track.
·      Redirection when you get off track.
PERSONAL CHEERLEADER:
·      Pats on the back and sends cyber chocolate when you doubt yourself.
·      Shoulder to cry on when a rejection is received and encouragement to keep going.

**With a Writing Coach: IT’S ALL ABOUT YOU.**




            CONS: Fee Service

After I wrote up this portion of my presentation, I sat back and was like, "Huh...I didn't intend to advertise the advantages of hiring a Writing Coach. It sounds like I'm really trying to sell myself." Believe me when I tell you I am not a salesperson. I wrote the information down and that's what I came up with, so take it as you will. Of course, I would love you to hire me as your Writing Coach. I offer a FREE 15 minute Phone Consultation. Get more information by visiting my website, Kim Briggs.  (That sounded an awful lot like a sales pitch, didn't it?)

Any who, I'd love to hear about your experience with Critique Groups and/or Writing Coaches. I'll even throw in a FREE Critique of your Query letter if you comment on the blog.

Sharing the writing love one letter at a time,
Kim 

Want to buy me a cup of chai? 











Size of mug
COMING UP: New Adult Scavenger Hunt kicks off April 26th. I'm on #TEAMBLUE with Valentine Kisses, so be sure to enter. There will be a lot of fantastic prizes including free books, gift cards, and other swag!! 

Popular posts from this blog

The Querying Writer: Part II

Dear Kim,


Remember that letter I sent you way back in October? (You remember October-- back when all things seemed possible.) 





The letter, COMP TITLES and THE QUERYING WRITER, shared details from our Novel Nuts & Bolts class with Empire Literary Agent Carrie Howland. (I may have referred to her as "agent-extraordinaire" in another post.)

Though today's post will be my third about Carrie, it is titled "Part II" because my querying journey seems sequel worthy.







I started looking for an agent soon after you and I met at the NYC SCBWI conference in 2012. I had nice feedback from an agent at a conference and sent him my work. His response was kind (which I've found most responses from agents to be.) But my writing wasn’t ready. The novel he saw was the first I’d ever finished. I wasn't ready.

I swallowed that little voice that said, SEND! SEND! SEND! for two more years until I entered #PitchWars-- Brenda Drake’s crash course in pitching. In the years between t…

Cover Reveal: The Perfect Trip by Stacy Barnett Mozer

Dear Alison,

Thank you for my letter on Friday. I was teaching and didn't get to read it until late Friday night, but oh the memories of our time at the Writing Barn...so wonderful, so peaceful, so inspiring. The retreat was a much needed break from the insane fall I've had, and though we worked our butts off, it was a different kind of work, a good kind of work, my favorite kind of work, and sharing that work with you and Donna? Yeah, that was awesome. I, too, was really able to dig into my WIP and find Gigi's voice. She's so different from Starr and with so much prep work on Starr Lost (Book Two) and Starr Gone (Book Three), I had a hard time recapturing Gigi's voice, but Texas changed all that. Her 'in your face' style sets the tone for the entire young adult urban fantasy series, and I can't get her defiant nature out of my head. (People, you've been warned.)

Alison, you and I get to share the writing love every Monday and Thursday. Today, I ge…

School Visit Recap: Assemblies to Workshops, and the CONVERSATIONS in between

Dear Kim (and friends),

This morning I put away my rainbow superhero mask, gold top hat, and banana-on-a-stick. Few things are sadder than closing your banana-on-a-stick into a dark closet. But, I guess it will rise again next month for my next school visit.

Oh, you thought my collection was somehow Halloween related? No, no. Just part of the workshop portion of my school visits. For the past two weeks I had the privilege of speaking to, and then with, students from one of our nearby districts.



Dwight Smith, the founder of My Special Word, joined me for the assembly portion of the event. We were able to share with the children Dwight's vision for the program, as well as my process for writing the books for him.

There was music. Lots of it.
Some singing. (Would you expect any less?)
And shouting! (Mostly the kids, but I got a few words in too.)



We met with over 800 kids during the assemblies and got a sense for how the school district planned to use My Special Word. I'll say,
w…